#methodological rigourShort comparison cannot isolate examination stress
One campus and one control catchment were observed around a single examination event without reported parallel-trends or placebo-event evidence. Campus-specific calendar changes and differences in contributors remain alternative explanations for the interaction.
↳ Methods, Wastewater sample collection and Data analysis; Discussion, limitations
#methodological rigourPopulation scaling and marker specificity remain unresolved
Campus loads rely on a fixed attendance-fraction adjustment, while examination-period mobility is not quantified. Non-specific oxidative markers and near-detection-limit control 8-OHG measurements add uncertainty to interpretation of the estimated magnitudes.
↳ Methods, Data analysis; Fig. 1 legend; Discussion, limitations
#reportingValidation language exceeds the measured evidence
The abstract claims identification of mental-health burden and the conclusion calls oxidative biomarkers validated. No independent psychological or clinical measure establishes that interpretation, and the limitations explicitly describe the markers as indirect.
↳ Abstract, final sentence; Discussion, limitations and closing paragraph