#methodological rigourBias safeguards and replicate units remain unclear
Blinded assessment of histology and electron microscopy is not reported. The statement that samples came from different dams does not explicitly define the statistical unit or explain handling of multiple littermates.
↳ Methods Sections 4.1, 4.4, 4.7–4.8
#reportingHSL no-effect wording exceeds measured evidence
The broad claim that HSL deficiency does not interfere with placental lipid metabolism exceeds the unchanged lipid concentrations: neutral CE hydrolase activity fell 35%, and cholesterol-synthesis gene expression fell more than 50%.
↳ Abstract; Introduction, final paragraph; Results Section 2.2
#methodological rigourHSL controls lack established maternal comparability
The reported HSL breeding cross cannot produce wild-type offspring, leaving the source of wild-type comparators and their maternal comparability unresolved. This limits interpretation of the negative HSL comparison.
↳ Methods Section 4.1; Results Section 2.2