#positioningAlternative explanations remain outside the conclusion
The Discussion does not explain how time, a new job or the reflective drawing process could account for change alongside programme attendance. A selected uncontrolled case cannot isolate the programme's contribution.
↳ Results, Time 2 and Time 3; Discussion, final three paragraphs
#methodological rigourReflexive procedures lack demonstrated interpretive consequences
A diary and clinical supervision are reported, but the account does not show how researcher position or service-linked supervision shaped interpretation. Coding development and co-author contributions are also described only in outline.
↳ Methods, Recruitment and data collection, final paragraph; Methods, Analysis
#reportingConfirmation language exceeds the case evidence
The assertion that the images confirm a self-management effect moves beyond documenting one participant's changing experience. The clearer distinction is between Jane's attribution of improvement and evidence identifying what caused it.
↳ Discussion, paragraph comparing the study with earlier visual research