OBJECTIVES: To assess the proportions of processed and ultraprocessed products in the UK that are high in fat, salt, and sugar, and energy density, defined by two systems used to regulate unhealthy food products in the UK (Food Standards Agency (FSA) nutrient profiling model (NPM) and front-of-pack traffic lights labelling system), and compared with UK dietary guidance based on new NPMs.
DESIGN: Cross sectional analysis of a nationally representative database of food and drink items.
SETTING: UK National Diet and Nutrition Survey database.
POPULATION: Food and drink items (262 processed products and 1636 ultraprocessed products) from the National Diet and Nutrition Survey database.
MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Proportion of processed and ultraprocessed products identified as unhealthy based on three Eatwell Guide NPMs, the FSA NPM, and the front-of-pack traffic lights labelling system. Three new nutrient profile models based on UK dietary guidance were constructed to identify excess saturated fat, free sugar, sodium, total fat, and energy density in processed and ultraprocessed products: NPM1 identified excess saturated fat, free sugar, and sodium; NPM2 identified excess saturated fat, free sugar, sodium, and total fat; and NPM3 identified excess saturated fat, free sugar, sodium, total fat, and energy density.
RESULTS: The proportion of ultraprocessed products identified as unhealthy differed significantly (P<0.05) between the NPMs. The FSA NPM identified as unhealthy 57.6% of ultraprocessed products (95% confidence interval 55.2% to 60.0%), whereas the traffic lights labelling system identified fewer than half of all ultraprocessed products as unhealthy (48.2%, 45.8% to 50.6%). NPM1 identified 91.5% (95% CI 90.2% to 92.9%) of all ultraprocessed products as unhealthy, model No 2 identified 94.9% (93.9% to 96.0%), and model No 3 identified 98.7% (98.2% to 99.3%) of all ultraprocessed products.
CONCLUSIONS: Food and drink products that, according to UK government dietary guidance, contain excess amounts of harmful nutrients are not identified by current systems for regulating UK food and drink (FSA NPM and front-of-pack traffic lights labelling system). The most conservative new NPM, based on current UK government dietary guidance, identified significantly greater proportions of processed and ultraprocessed products as unhealthy than the current two systems. These findings have important implications for food policy and the appropriateness of UK dietary guidance to identify unhealthy products.