#methodological rigourMetabolic rescue language exceeds demonstrated target engagement
PGC-1α-associated transport rescue is reported, but astrocytic respiration shows only a nonsignificant trend in one tested line. The claimed causal metabolic link also lacks an empty-vector comparison across the rescue lines, with TFAM-GFP providing only partial control.
↳ Abstract; Fig. 3; Discussion; Extended Data Fig. 5b–j
#positioningNeuronal coverage limits generalization beyond tested cultures
The hiPSC motor-neuron experiments use one mutant/gene-corrected pair, supplemented by a control hESC line for selected comparisons. This constraint receives little interpretive discussion despite its importance for generalization.
↳ Fig. 1 legend; Extended Data Fig. 2a; Methods, hiPSC MN generation; Discussion
#reportingExclusion statements and condition labels need reconciliation
The Reporting Summary declares no exclusions, whereas Methods describes excluding negative ECAR values. Figure 2a,b also repeats the same condition label with n = 10, 19 and 17, leaving group identification ambiguous.
↳ Reporting Summary, Data exclusions; Methods, Glycolytic rate measurement; Fig. 2a,b legend