#reportingPractical autonomy framing exceeds retrospective validation
The abstract's practical-framework interpretation rests on an operating point assessed on the same MIRA-v2 cohort: 98.9% accuracy at 49.4% coverage. VivaBench reaches 89.9% at 32.0% coverage, and prospective clinical routing safety is not established.
↳ Abstract, final sentence; Fig. 6; Extended Data Fig. 4c; Discussion, limitations
#methodological rigourCase-level correctness construction remains insufficiently explicit
GLM-4.5-Air has an 88.4% five-run mean in the model comparison, while the confidence and triage baseline contains 499 correct cases out of 551, or 90.6%. These need not conflict, but the mapping from repeated runs to binary case-level correctness is not fully explained.
↳ Results, On-premise agent achieves competitive diagnostic performance; Fig. 3 legend; Fig. 5 legend; Methods, Multi-perspective confidence framework
#positioningExternal access boundary is not reconciled
The ethics statement says clinical text was inaccessible to external providers, yet the study reports a cloud GPT-5.2 baseline and an API-based Gemini evaluator. The text does not explain how these uses fit the stated governance boundary.
↳ Methods, Ethics statement and Performance evaluation; Results, model comparison; Extended Data Table 2