#methodological rigourPopulation purity and differentiation controls remain unresolved
The gated population averaged 20.3% CD45-positive cells despite the paper's CD45-negative MSC definition. Untreated controls also showed myocyte differentiation, limiting that assay's specificity.
↳ Introduction; Sections 3.2 and 3.4; Figures 2 and 4
#methodological rigourExperimental contrasts cannot identify broader biological claims
Static cell-cluster comparisons do not establish a lineage transition, combined MPA–cAMP treatment cannot isolate progesterone effects, and stained-area fractions do not directly identify changes in cell abundance.
↳ Sections 2.4, 2.9, 2.13 and 3.6; Figures 1 and 6
#positioningPreserved function exceeds the acknowledged culture limitations
The Abstract's intact-function conclusion rests on small, non-equivalence comparisons after culture expansion. The Discussion itself explains that expansion and dedifferentiation could make term-derived cells resemble non-pregnant cells.
↳ Abstract; Sections 3.2–3.3; Discussion, culture limitations